I was reading about the demise of CCM, the magazine
American Evangelicalism created its own little world where it is of the world but not in it, otherwise completely bass ackwards of what our Lord said. It allows for the support of many people who otherwise would be doing more fulfilling work, like mowing the lawn or riveting wings together rather than making awful music.
This fact caused me to create a rule of thumb which, in general, works. Simply put, I believe the more mainstream the style a given Christian artist plays, the more likely that artists is bad compared to his contemporaries in the secular music scene. The consequence of this is the more obscure the style of music, the more likely the artist will be good, if not at the top of the heap. This is especially true in some of the more obscure metal subgeneras where the "Christian" artists can outplay and outriff their secular counterparts. One of the classic albums in doom metal, for instance, is by a band called Paramecium. Exhumed of the Earth is an interesting album, if nothing else for its telling of the life of Christ. It contains one of the most depressing Christmas songs ever recorded (it reminds us our Lord's first throne was a feeding trough before a throne room filled with less than sanitary stuff). This album is considered a classic by many in the death/doom subgenera. I would love to tell you more, but the CD is buried under a pile of Michael W. Smith, DC Talk, and other not quite ready for primetime bands and artists. The band Touriquet is another example. Having one of the best drummers period really helps in gaining credibility, along with an ability to write more riffs in one song than many bands write in a career. Extol is another band who has a lot of credibility with the secular crowd. Their album Undeceived sent them skyrocketing in the death metal genera.
Do I still listen? I pull out a tourniquet CD every now and then, and I used to use some of the songs by Extol to work out to. In the end, however, I prefer listening to Bach or Johnny Cash over what I used to listen to. I think my daughter would be frightened if I started listening again. Besides, Bach and Mozart are better for her and for me.

